07 Mar
Posted by ericmsteen as Movies, Sci-Fi, Sci-Fi and Activsim, Utopian Visions
In almost all post-apocalyptic films we see the destruction and disintigration of life as we know it. Because of famine, plague, disease, war, natural disasters, or a slew of other “acts of God” the framework that human kind has built comes to a screeching halt and humans are forced to rethink how to proceed. I want something new! Most of the post apocalyptic movies we currently see do one of three things:
Either spend the majority of their time portraying the destruction of the world…
…OR the main character goes from place to place encountering various groups of the oppressed, or oppressors in search of some greater meaning. Often the groups are subcultures who have formed localized militia out of the rubble…
…OR they show how, after the chaos of the apocalypse, a dystopian government has risen to oppress the people.
The dystopian variety are my favorite version of post-apocalypse because they often envision a place where people are nothing more than machines, property of the state, or tools for profit. Much of the way our world functions, in the 1st world and in the so-called 3rd world, is like this even though there has not necessarily been any apocalypse. Many of the movies are warnings about our behavior towards other humans as well as our behavior toward our planet.
I see many of these post-apocalyptic movies warning us but I see very little in the line of suggestions for post-apocalyptic living or specific life-changing prescriptions for our current situations. What I would like to see is more movies where we see the apocalypse, but then we ALSO see how hard work, changing our life-style, and being supportive can bring communities together. I don’t want just a “look we saved the day by killing the enemies” ending or a “we found the cure that saved the world” ending, but I want a film full of actual steps toward making our world a better place to live in. How do we do that?
Movies like Wall-E are a step in the correct direction. In Wall-E we experience the future consequences of OUR current actions and decisions. But we see a group of people that learn how to reclaim the land, grow their own food, and learn how to incorporate human interaction back into their lifestyles. I would have loved to see more of the clean-up and rebuilding of the dirty earth. What would the new economy and political structures look like? Why end the movie right as they enter the New World?
Let’s look at the 2008 version of The Day The Earth Stood Still. Regardless of whether or not we think the movie is successful or not, I thought the issues being raised were pertinent and similar to that of Wall-E. The earth is at a point where it’s in crisis mode and we can avoid the apocalypse if we change. However, the place where this movie ends is when one or two people convince the aliens that humans can change. We don’t get to see any of that change, and we aren’t really even convinced that our main characters care all too much about the state of the earth, but imagine if the aliens had put some demand and ultimatum on the humans where we got to see them restructure everything and attempt to turn everything into sustainable systems. Maybe that would be boring, but don’t you want to at least have some time to imagine what this new system could look like? How would humans change the world in one year if they were given that ultimatum? How could we get creative quickly? I think that could be wild. Agree?

Besides Wall-E, another movie that adds to this conversation is the 1970 film Gas-s-s-s. I don’t necessarily recommend the movie to anyone; I thought it was quite bad. In it, there is a gas that kills everyone in the world over 25 and a group of young hippy-types travel across the country in search of some sort of meaning. I’m less interested in their quest for meaning than I am in the very last scene. They ended up finding a place that just threw a big party and that was how they solved the problem of hatred and oppression in the world. While I think it’s a really silly idea to think that just throwing a party will make everything better, I do think that, in some ways, this movie addresses the need for community, friends and a sense of family. The movie itself doesn’t do a good job, but it has some little nuggets that are interesting. I would like to see what happens post-party. Partying will not solve the world problems, but it could create a very temporary moment of togetherness. Can this moment of togetherness leave enough positive residue to form a community of people that will work together? What would that look like? Would it look anything like the movie Commune? How does a community congegrate post-apocalyptic style?
My problem is that most of these movies end right as the movie is getting good. I want to see the aftermath, I want to see the challenges. I don’t want to just see that the world was saved, or that meaning was found, I want to see things being rebuilt and I want to see how to form communities. I want to see how a vision for a better place is addressed after the life as we know it disintegrates. Does anyone else agree with me? Maybe one thing that I will do on this blog now is offer alternative endings to the post-apocalyptic movies I’m watching.
10 Responses
Eriq Nelson
March 9th, 2009 at 9:46 am
1I just finished reading a book that spends a good deal of time confronting a post-apocalyptic scenario. The Fifth Sacred Thing by Starhawk ( http://tinyurl.com/apan86 ) does a good job of explaining the political and social structures that evolve in a ruined world. Some of the methods the characters employ are pure fantasy, but the social structures are quite in tune with human nature. I’ve been thinking a lot about utopia/dystopia recently and there is precious little beyond this book that fills both roles adequately.
Chris Hunt
March 10th, 2009 at 2:51 pm
2I couldn’t agree more. I’m currently working on a comic right now that focus’s on the restructuring of a post apocalyptic world after an economic collapse. My main issue is that if its not a dystopian story, the story seems like it HAS to involve world wide destruction, zombies, or radiation. What if infrastructure just went away along with law and order? What would appear in the vacuum? To me, those are the more interesting questions to ask.
Andre Canivet
March 10th, 2009 at 8:15 pm
3Eric (is that right?) you’ve got it right on the money. I’ve felt the same way for some time–there’s all these stories about the end of the world, but almost never one about the beginning of a new and happier one.
Ian Pattinson
March 11th, 2009 at 2:03 am
4Please allow me a little self promotion.
Not a movie, and not a full on apocalypse, but I’m currently working on a novel about rebuilding society after a war between the US and Old Europe. The narrator returns home after five years chronicling the war to find out how it has affected family, friends and the city he left in the (officially) neutral UK.
Firt drafts of the chapters are going up at http://www.spinneyhead.co.uk/labels/Sounds%20of%20Soldiers.php as they’re written.
It’s the first of what could be a series of stories looking st standards from a different angle. Next up, possibly, is a less militaristic space opera- taking the sort of premise often found in military SF but giving the weaponry and hardware to people other than the US government. Then there’s the virus that doesn’t turn people into zombies, but does change their bodies significantly.
VanRabbit
March 11th, 2009 at 5:12 pm
5We’re talking about a very wide range of films here, both in where they derive their archetypes and also narrative structure. It’s almost silly to imagine a version of Mad Max where he settles down and gets fat tending the land, or a world where Snake Plisken decides to reform and become the government’s bitch etc.
I honestly believe most of these movies would actually do the inverse of improve if the end were to be that drastically altered or extended to include a “rebuilding” section. I think that’s missing the point. Even with the most delicate of additions to the plot you’d be drastically altering the tone of these films. While it is might be viable to produce a good film based on what you describe as lacking from the genre I think it’d have to be specifically written as such.
I will concede that you can modify a lot of post apocalyptic conventions to fit a film more focused on rebuilding etc. Zombie films would be an easy first choice, many of which have already broached the topic of rebuilding if not confronted it directly.
Waterworld almost has the kind of ending you describe as being too abrupt. It’s worthy to note the film is built on the western genre’s themes and archetypes and as such it’s not totally unrealistic for me to envision a post apocalyptic film that is essentially a rehashing of the kinds of western films that dealt with the Reconstruction era of the United States (forgive the wiki verbatim).
In the end I’m not sure if the “Gone With the Wind” of post apocalyptic movies really needs to be made but I suppose I’d give it a shot.
Prakash
March 12th, 2009 at 12:50 am
6Postman by david brin does take into account a little re-building after the apocalyptic events. the movie, though not great is still quite an OK watch.
AZMos
March 17th, 2009 at 4:43 pm
7Can’t think of movies that do what you ask, but can think of two books.
One is Nightfall by Asimov. The short story ends with an “apocalypse” of sorts. The book, written later and inferior to the short story (imo), continues with the story of the rebuilding.
A great book that does this is “A Canticle for Leibowitz” which goes through the rebuilding process after nuclear war. Over three generations time periods it really shows how society develops after destroying itself.
Sci Fi Double Feature Recommendation #04 | Beer and Sci-Fi
March 18th, 2009 at 8:25 am
8[...] partly by my recent post about how post-apocalyptic movies should start focusing on rebuilding the world after it [...]
Die Neue Utopische Post-Apokalypse « mutanten.org
April 1st, 2010 at 10:09 am
9[...] zu artikel und diskussion [...]
Michaela Hutfles
August 10th, 2011 at 2:08 pm
10We thought the problem was serious enough to do something about it. We’re publishing a whole anthology of what happens after the aftermath. Looking for submission through August 31, 2011 & will be publishing it in November-ish. Feel free to add something or enjoy a copy and let us know what you think.
Michaela
Producer, Timid Pirate Publishing
RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI
Leave a reply
Compute:
Most Recent Posts
My Most Popular Posts
Archive by Topic
Monthly Archive
Like My Content?
Beer (Colorado)
Beer (Oregon)
Beer (UK)
Other Favorites
Sci-Fi Links
Administrate!
Beer and Sci-Fi receives power that exudes from WordPress - BloggingPro theme by: Design Disease